Kalish or Sloan - Page 2

Blue Ranger Gone Bad · 04/06/17, 08:18 PM

I agree , Sloan was the much better writer. People used to be way too hard on Kalish. Mostly.because he didn't interview well.

Polly Want A Megazord · 04/06/17, 09:48 PM

I like them both..

MMPR Forever · 04/10/17, 12:54 AM

Im surprised Sloan didn't do a better job since he was such a big part of MMPR.

Disney Ranger · 04/10/17, 12:57 AM

Perhaps Saban's people had to micro-managing him during MMPR like Disney did with nNinja Storm and DinoThunder..

MMPR Forever · 04/10/17, 05:38 PM

Sloan since he worked on MMPR at least.

Saban Fan · 04/10/17, 05:39 PM

Its hard to say since I liked the ahow under Sloan better during his first run, but that was mostly do to Saban. I would say they are even. Since both underwhelmed without Saban tk answer to.

Goldar's Revenge · 04/11/17, 12:20 PM

Saban has largely been the money guy and promoted the show in the media. He gets credit for coming up with the concept of the show and adapting Sentai. Plus he did read over the scripts in season.1. But for the most part he has let creative do its own thing. He isn't really a writer or tv producer in the conventional sense..Sloan worked under Levy during his first run. With Tzachor being the showrrunner by the time he left. When he returned Sloan only had to answer to Disney. The same with Kalish's run.

Uncle Steve · 04/14/17, 11:15 PM

Sloan understood Power Rangers more than Kalish.

Doomsday · 04/15/17, 08:03 AM

Doug Sloan is one of the best. Kalish is a good tv writer but didn't entirely understand he show.

Rangerlord · 04/19/17, 11:28 AM

I think Sloan had a better understanding of continuity.

04/06/17, 08:18 PM	#11
Blue Ranger Gone Bad Ranger In Training Join Date: 09/11/16 Posts: 91	Re: Kalish or Sloan I agree , Sloan was the much better writer. People used to be way too hard on Kalish. Mostly.because he didn't interview well.

04/06/17, 09:48 PM	#12
Polly Want A Megazord Comic Relief Join Date: 02/11/17 Posts: 45	Re: Kalish or Sloan I like them both..

04/10/17, 12:54 AM	#13
MMPR Forever Power Ranger Join Date: 12/16/14 Posts: 600	Re: Kalish or Sloan Im surprised Sloan didn't do a better job since he was such a big part of MMPR.

04/10/17, 12:57 AM	#14
Disney Ranger Power Ranger Join Date: 04/30/11 Posts: 183	Re: Kalish or Sloan Perhaps Saban's people had to micro-managing him during MMPR like Disney did with nNinja Storm and DinoThunder..

04/10/17, 05:38 PM	#15
MMPR Forever Power Ranger Join Date: 12/16/14 Posts: 600	Re: Kalish or Sloan Sloan since he worked on MMPR at least.

04/10/17, 05:39 PM	#16
Saban Fan Ranger In Training Join Date: 12/13/16 Posts: 77	Re: Kalish or Sloan Its hard to say since I liked the ahow under Sloan better during his first run, but that was mostly do to Saban. I would say they are even. Since both underwhelmed without Saban tk answer to.

04/11/17, 12:20 PM	#17
Goldar's Revenge Power Ranger Join Date: 09/14/16 Posts: 575	Re: Kalish or Sloan Saban has largely been the money guy and promoted the show in the media. He gets credit for coming up with the concept of the show and adapting Sentai. Plus he did read over the scripts in season.1. But for the most part he has let creative do its own thing. He isn't really a writer or tv producer in the conventional sense..Sloan worked under Levy during his first run. With Tzachor being the showrrunner by the time he left. When he returned Sloan only had to answer to Disney. The same with Kalish's run.

04/14/17, 11:15 PM	#18
Uncle Steve Ranger In Training Join Date: 06/23/15 Posts: 58	Re: Kalish or Sloan Sloan understood Power Rangers more than Kalish.

04/15/17, 08:03 AM	#19
Doomsday Comic Relief Join Date: 02/27/15 Posts: 41	Re: Kalish or Sloan Doug Sloan is one of the best. Kalish is a good tv writer but didn't entirely understand he show.

04/19/17, 11:28 AM	#20
Rangerlord Power Ranger Join Date: 06/09/15 Posts: 135	Re: Kalish or Sloan I think Sloan had a better understanding of continuity.